Who Is Responsible for Repairs: The HOA or the Homeowner?
By Zachary Wallman, Founder of HOA Reviewer
One of the biggest frustrations homeowners experience is trying to figure out who is responsible for a repair.
A roof starts leaking. A pipe breaks. Exterior paint begins peeling. A tree damages a common area. Suddenly, the homeowner and HOA are disagreeing about who should pay for the work.
In HOA communities, maintenance responsibilities aren’t always obvious. The association may be responsible for certain common areas while homeowners are responsible for their individual properties. In condominium communities, responsibilities can be even more complicated.
So how do you determine whether the HOA should handle a repair or whether the expense falls on you?
The answer usually starts with your governing documents.
Why Maintenance Responsibilities Can Be Confusing
HOA communities are structured differently.
In some communities, homeowners are responsible for nearly everything within their individual lots, while the association maintains shared amenities and common areas.
In condominium communities, the association may have responsibility for portions of the building, including certain structural elements or shared systems, while owners are responsible for their individual units.
However, these are general patterns, not universal rules.
Your HOA’s declaration, maintenance provisions, property boundaries, insurance policies, and applicable state law may determine who is responsible for a particular repair.
1. Who Is Responsible for the Roof?
Roof responsibility is one of the most common HOA maintenance disputes.
In a single-family community, homeowners may be responsible for maintaining and repairing their own roofs, even if the HOA regulates roofing materials, colors, or replacement standards.
In some communities, however, the HOA maintains or replaces roofs as part of its association responsibilities.
In condominium communities, the association may be responsible for the building’s roof, but the governing documents and applicable law determine the exact obligations.
Before scheduling a repair or assuming the HOA will pay, review the maintenance provisions and ask the association to clarify its responsibilities.
2. Who Is Responsible for Plumbing?
Plumbing responsibility can depend on where the problem is located and which components serve the property.
A homeowner may be responsible for plumbing fixtures and pipes serving their individual home or unit, while the HOA may be responsible for shared plumbing infrastructure.
But determining responsibility isn’t always as simple as identifying where a leak appears.
For example, a leak inside a homeowner’s property may originate from a shared pipe or another unit. The source of the damage, the system involved, and the governing documents may affect responsibility for repairs and resulting damage.
If you experience a plumbing problem, notify the HOA promptly if shared infrastructure may be involved.
Document the damage, keep repair records, and avoid assuming responsibility until the situation is properly evaluated.
3. Who Maintains Exterior Walls and Paint?
Exterior maintenance requirements vary significantly between HOAs.
Some associations maintain exterior walls, siding, stucco, trim, and paint throughout the community. Other associations require homeowners to maintain those features themselves while enforcing standards for appearance.
An HOA may also require architectural approval before homeowners repaint, replace siding, or make exterior modifications.
If your exterior needs repair, determine whether the association is responsible for completing the work or whether you’re required to hire a contractor and obtain approval.
4. Who Is Responsible for Balconies, Patios, and Fences?
Balconies, patios, fences, and other exterior features can create disputes because they may be assigned different maintenance responsibilities depending on the community.
A balcony may be part of a condominium unit, a limited common element, or a shared structural component.
A fence may belong to an individual homeowner, be shared between neighboring properties, or be maintained by the association.
Patios and private outdoor spaces may also have specific maintenance requirements.
Review the governing documents to determine whether the feature is classified as a common area, limited common area, or part of your property.
The classification can affect who pays for repairs and who is allowed to make modifications.
5. What About Landscaping and Trees?
Landscaping responsibilities are another frequent source of confusion.
In some communities, homeowners maintain landscaping within their own lots while the HOA maintains community entrances, common areas, and shared landscaping.
In other communities, the HOA handles landscaping throughout the neighborhood, including areas surrounding individual homes.
Tree maintenance can become particularly complicated when a tree is located near property boundaries, common areas, sidewalks, or shared infrastructure.
If a tree causes damage or creates a safety concern, report it promptly and ask the HOA to clarify responsibility before arranging work that may require approval.
6. Who Pays for Damage Caused by a Common Area?
What happens if an HOA-maintained area causes damage to your property?
For example:
- A common-area tree damages your fence.
- A shared irrigation system leaks onto your property.
- Water from a common building component causes damage inside your home.
- A common-area drainage problem affects your yard.
Responsibility may depend on the source of the damage, maintenance obligations, insurance coverage, applicable law, and the circumstances involved.
Don’t assume the HOA automatically owes compensation just because the damage originated near a common area.
Document the damage, notify the association in writing, preserve repair estimates, and ask how the association intends to address the problem.
7. What Should You Do When the HOA Refuses to Make a Repair?
If you believe the HOA is responsible for a repair but the association refuses to address it, start by gathering the relevant information.
Review the governing documents and identify the maintenance provision you believe applies.
Then:
- Photograph the problem.
- Document when it started.
- Keep copies of maintenance requests.
- Request a written explanation from the HOA.
- Ask the association to identify the provision it relies on if it denies responsibility.
- Follow the HOA’s formal complaint or dispute procedures.
If the repair involves water damage, structural problems, electrical hazards, or another urgent safety issue, don’t wait indefinitely for an HOA response. Take appropriate steps to protect yourself and your property while documenting the situation.
If the association continues to ignore your requests, see our guide on what to do when your HOA board ignores homeowners for additional steps you can take to get a response.
Depending on the seriousness of the dispute, you may need to seek professional advice.
8. Check Your HOA Documents Before You Assume
The most important step is reviewing the documents that establish your HOA’s responsibilities.
Look for:
- Maintenance and repair provisions.
- Common-area definitions.
- Limited common-area provisions.
- Unit or lot boundaries.
- Insurance responsibilities.
- Repair and replacement obligations.
- Rules regarding owner modifications.
- Damage and liability provisions.
If the documents are unclear, ask the association for clarification in writing.
HOA Maintenance Responsibilities Can Affect Your Cost of Ownership
Maintenance responsibilities can make a significant difference in the true cost of owning a home.
A property may appear affordable until you discover that homeowners are responsible for major exterior repairs, plumbing components, roofs, or other expensive items.
Before purchasing, find out what the HOA actually maintains, how repairs are handled, and whether homeowners have reported recurring maintenance problems.
Don’t just research the house. Research the HOA.
Understanding maintenance responsibilities before you buy can help you avoid unexpected expenses and frustrating disputes later.

